Research Article |
Corresponding author: Sayaka Sogawa ( ssogawa@affrc.go.jp ) Academic editor: Dirk Steinke
© 2022 Sayaka Sogawa, Kenji Tsuchiya, Satoshi Nagai, Shinji Shimode, Victor S. Kuwahara.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Sogawa S, Tsuchiya K, Nagai S, Shimode S, Kuwahara VS (2022) Annual dynamics of eukaryotic and bacterial communities revealed by 18S and 16S rRNA metabarcoding in the coastal ecosystem of Sagami Bay, Japan. Metabarcoding and Metagenomics 6: e78181. https://doi.org/10.3897/mbmg.6.78181
|
Sagami Bay, Japan is influenced by both the warm Kuroshio Current and the cold Oyashio Current and rich nutrients are supplied from multiple river sources and the deep-sea, forming a dynamic ecosystem. The aim of the present study was to investigate eukaryotic and bacterial communities in the coastal waters of Sagami Bay, using 16S rRNA and 18S rRNA sequencing and to assess the seasonal and vertical dynamics in relation to physicochemical and biological conditions. Eukaryotic and bacterial communities showed synchronous seasonal and vertical changes along with environmental variability. Diversity of plankton community suspended in the surface was lower than those at the subsurface layers in both the eukaryotes and bacteria communities; however, community diversity showed different characteristics in the subsurface where the eukaryotic community at the deeper layer (100 m) was as low as the surface and highest in intermediate depth layers (10–50 m), while that of bacterial community was highest in the deeper layer (100 m). The annual variability of the coastal microbial communities was driven, not only by the seasonal changes of abiotic and biotic factors and short-term rapid changes by river water inflow and phytoplankton blooms, but also largely influenced by deep-seawater upwellings due to the unique seafloor topography.
bacteria, bloom, coastal marine ecosystem, deep seawater, environmental factor, microbial plankton, phytoplankton, zooplankton
Marine pelagic ecosystems are interconnected by two types of food chains: grazing food chains and microbial food chains (microbial loop). Classical grazing food chains begin with phytoplankton photosynthesis (producers), which become food for zooplankton, such as herbivorous copepods and further preyed upon by larger organisms, such as fishes (
Sagami Bay, located on the Pacific Ocean side of middle Honshu Island, Japan, is known for its variety of aquatic landform, containing rivers (terrestrial runoff), coastal zones and deep seas (deeper than 1,000 m). Abundant nutrients are supplied from multiple river sources and deep ocean upwelling, forming rich harvest grounds containing a wide variety of migratory and local fishery catch. The Bay is influenced by both warm Kuroshio and cold Oyashio currents: Kuroshio, the western boundary current of the North Pacific subtropical gyre, transports warm and saline subtropical waters as well as a diverse assortment of organisms and Oyashio, the western boundary current of the western subarctic gyre, branches and flows from the opposite direction of Kuroshio in the mesopelagic layer and flows into Sagami Bay. Consequently, the Bay would be an appropriate location for monitoring diverse plankton communities and survey of the area could provide indispensable information towards understanding the coastal aquatic ecosystem. Previous studies reported temporal/seasonal variation of bacterio-, phyto- and zooplankton in Sagami Bay and their ecology in relation to environmental factors. (
Seasonal observations were carried out at the shelf station (120 m depths, latitude 35°09.75'N, 139°10.00'E longitude), located in the western part of Sagami Bay (Fig.
Survey dates in Sagami Bay. Asterisks represent sampling only on the surface.
Year | Month and day |
---|---|
2018 | Oct (18th), Nov (15th), Dec (13th) |
2019 | Feb (14th), Mar (17th), Apr (19th), May (17th, 24th* and 31st*), Jun (14th), Jul (9th*, 12th and 31st*), Aug (6th*), Sep (30th*), Nov (15th and 25th*), Dec (10th* and 20th) |
2020 | Jan (6th* and 31st*), Feb (4th* and 20th) |
Schematic illustration of surface current around Japan (left) and location of survey site (right, red circle) in Sagami Bay, Japan.
Vertical profiles of temperature, salinity, density, chlorophyll a fluorescence and dissolved oxygen were measured continuously using a RINKO-Profiler (ASTD102, JFE Advantech Co., Ltd). Mixed layer depths (MLDs) were calculated from density with the following equation: MLD: Δσt(z) = σt(z) – σt(5m) > 0.125 kg/m3 (
For detection of eukaryotic and bacterial communities, respectively primer pairs of V7–9 region in 18S-rRNA gene (18S-V7F: TGGAGYGATHTGTCTGGTTDATTCCG and 18S-V9R: TCACCTACGGAWACCTTGTTACG;
Nucleotide sequences were demultiplexed depending on the 5′-multiplex identifier tag and primer sequences according to the default format in MiSeq. Sequences longer than 300 bp were truncated to 300 bp by trimming the 30 tails. The trimmed sequences shorter than 250 bp were filtered out. Demultiplexing and trimming were performed using Trimmomatic version 0.35. The remaining sequences were merged into paired reads using Usearch version 8.0.1517. In addition, singletons were removed. Sequences were then aligned using Clustal Omega version 1.2.0. Multiple sequences were aligned with each other and only sequences that were contained in more than 75% of the read positions were extracted. Filtering and part of the multiple alignment process were performed as described in the Miseq standard operating procedure using Mothur (
The sequence database used to identify OTUs was downloaded from GenBank on 20 August 2020. The taxonomic identification of each OTU was performed by the BLAST search (
All multivariate analyses of eukaryotic community structure and diversity were performed using PRIMER version 7 with PERMANOVA+ add-on software (
Vertical profiles of temperature, salinity, density, chlorophyll fluorescence, dissolved oxygen and nutrients in Sagami Bay during the observation period are shown in Fig.
In the study area, 1,660 OTUs (985 OTUs from the surface) of eukaryotic plankton were detected. Supergroup Alveolata was the largest of 658 OTUs (377 OTUs from the surface), followed by Stramenopiles of 368 OTUs (259 OTUs), Opisthokonta of 262 OTUs (131 OTUs), Rhizaria of 160 OTUs (77 OTUs), Hacrobia of 90 OTUs (66 OTUs) and Viridiplantae of 77 OTUs (50 OTUs). The number of OTUs detected in the study area were ca. three times larger in the bacterial community (4477 OTUs and 2838 OTUs from the surface). Phylum Proteobacteria was the largest of 2483 OTUs (1573 OTUs from the surface), followed by Bacteroidota of 1067 (786 OTUs), Verrucomicrobiota of 112 (66 OTUs), Actinobacteriota of 87 (70 OTUs), Bdellovibrionota of 78 OTUs (31 OTUs) and Cyanobacteria of 71 (56 OTUs).
Diversity analysis was conducted for eukaryotic community amongst depths (Fig.
Species richness, Shannon-Wiener Diversity (H′) and Pielou’s Evenness (J′) of eukaryotic and bacterial communities in Sagami Bay comparing amongst sampling depth layers.
Sample-based rarefaction curves of each sampling depth layer of eukaryotic and bacterial community.
Diversity analysis was also conducted for bacterial community amongst depths (Fig.
The ANOSIM test revealed significant differences amongst months for both eukaryotic and bacterial community (global test: R = 0.395, P = 0.001 for 18S and R = 0.701, P = 0.001 for 16S). On the contrary, there were no significant differences amongst depth layers for both the eukaryotic and bacterial communities (ANOSIM global test: R = 0.009, P = 0.389 for 18S and R = 0.005, P = 0.470 for 16S). NMDS ordination represented samples collected in similar seasons (months) and depth layers are plotted closer, particularly during winter (Fig.
Non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) ordination of eukaryotic (upper figures) and bacterial communities (lower figures) in Sagami Bay. Coloured area showed plot ranges of each depth layer (left figures) and each month (right figures). Numbers in parenthesis after month represent year of sampling; “18” as 2018, “19” as 2019 and “20” as 2020.
Distance-based multivariate linear model (DISTLM) analysis revealed significant relationships (p < 0.01) between eight out of nine variables and eukaryotic and bacterial community structures, respectively (Table
Percentage of variation explained in a distance-based multivariate linear model (DISTLIM) of eukaryotes and bacterial community.
Marginal Tests (18S) | Marginal Tests (16S) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Variable | p | Variation explained (%) | Variable | p | Variation explained (%) |
MLD | 0.0001 | 11.48 | MLD | 0.0001 | 11.60 |
Nitrate + nitrite | 0.0001 | 8.25 | Density | 0.0001 | 9.95 |
Density | 0.0001 | 7.44 | EZ1% | 0.0001 | 9.75 |
Chlorophyll a | 0.0001 | 6.46 | Nitrate + nitrite | 0.0001 | 9.31 |
EZ1% | 0.0001 | 6.45 | Chlorophyll a | 0.0001 | 8.71 |
Temp | 0.0001 | 4.25 | Month | 0.0001 | 8.04 |
Month | 0.0003 | 3.82 | Temp | 0.0001 | 5.15 |
Silica | 0.0009 | 3.45 | Silica | 0.0002 | 4.75 |
Sal | 0.5616 | 1.07 | Sal | 0.4044 | 1.37 |
Distance-based redundancy analysis (DBRDA) ordination of eukaryotic and bacterial community. The distance-based redundancy analysis was constrained by the best-fit explanatory variables from a distance-based multivariate linear model (DISTLM).
In the top 10 OTU of eukaryotic communities, Amobophyra (Alveolata, Dinophyceae) and Astrosphaera (Rhizaria, Polycystinea), which were abundant at 100 m depths, were positively related to nitrate + nitrite and negatively related to chlorophyll a (Fig.
MLDs also accounted for the largest proportion of fitted variance for bacterial community, followed by density, EZ1%, nitrate + nitrite and chlorophyll a (11.6–8.7%) (Table
In the top 10 OTU of bacterial communities, Flavobacteriales, Cellvibrionales and Rhodobacterales, which were abundant in spring and summer, were positively related to chlorophyll a and negatively related to MLDs (Fig.
Bacterial communities were classified into four clusters at 30% of the Bray-Curtis Similarity in cluster analysis (Fig.
Taxonomic relative contributions of top 30 abundant Order (on average) to the bacterioplankton faction for each cluster.
SAR11 subclade Ia was dominant in SAR11 clade (53.1 ± 16.1%, Suppl. material
The eukaryotic community was classified into seven clusters, which represent clear seasonal and vertical patterns (Fig.
The taxonomic groups of phytoplankton (diatom, dinoflagellates, haptophytes and green algae) were represented by heatmap at class level (Fig.
Heatmap of taxonomic groups that include phytoplankton community (diatom, dinoflagellates, haptophytes and green algae) at class levels identified by 18S rRNA in Sagami Bay. The colour scale of the heatmap indicates relative abundance in reads between the samples, colour red indicates larger abundance and blue indicates smaller abundance.
Additional cluster analysis was conducted for each taxonomic group that include phytoplankton community (diatom 223 OTUs, dinoflagellates 489 OTUs, green algae 77 OTUs and haptophytes 60 OTUs) and relative abundance top 15 OTUs classified to species level (Suppl. material
Amongst dinoflagellates, Karlodinium veneficum (12.6%) most dominated in relative reads abundance, followed by Heterocapsa rotundata (8.0%), Noctiluca scintillans (5.2%), Pentapharsodinium tyrrhenicum (4.4%), Takayama cf. pulchellum (2.3%), Prorocentrum micans (1.8%) and Lepidodinium viride (1.3%). Karlodinium veneficum was relatively abundant throughout the survey period, especially dominant at 50 m depths in March–June. Heterocapsa rotundata dominated at the surface in May–September and at the subsurface layer (30–100 m) in November. Noctiluca scintillans was locally abundant at the surface in May and July and near the surface in November. Pentapharsodinium tyrrhenicum was relatively abundant in the subsurface layer throughout the survey period, especially at 100 m depth and Parvodinium inconspicuum at 100 m depths in February.
Sequence reads abundance of haptophytes had an overall peak in April at depths shallower than 30 m. Amongst haptophytes, Chrysochromulina scutellum most dominated in relative reads abundance (13.5%), followed by Prymnesium pigrum (13.3%), Chrysochromulina simplex (10.9%), Phaeocystis globose (10.6%), Prymnesium kappa (3.6%), Phaeocystis cordata (3.0%), Chrysochromulina campanulifera (1.7%), Prymnesium palpebrale (1.5%), Haptolina fragaria (1.3%) and Chrysochromulina strobilus (1.3%). Chrysochromulina scutellum occurred throughout the survey period. Prymnesium pigrum was relatively abundant in winter at depths shallower than 50 m. Chrysochromulina simplex also occurred throughout the survey period, but dominated in May–July and P. globosa at the 100 m depths.
Sequence reads abundance of green algae overall peaked in winter. Amongst green algae, Ostreococcus tauri (%) most dominated in relative reads abundance (27.0%), followed by Micromonas pusilla (20.5%), Bathycoccus prasinos (14.6%), Mantoniella squamata (5.1%), Pycnococcus provasolii (3.3%), Pyramimonas disomata (0.4%) and Pyramimonas australis (0.3%). Ostreococcus tauri dominated in December–June. Micromonas pusilla and Bathycoccus prasinos dominated in October–July and October–March, respectively.
Astrosphaera hexagonalis/ Arachnosphaera myriacantha (radiolarian, Rhizaria) dominated in cluster 1 (October 2018 at 100 m depth) of eukaryotic community (75.3%). These species form a monophyletic group by molecular phylogenetic analysis using 18S rRNA gene (
The genus Amoebophrya is known to parasitise on a wide range of other dinoflagellates (
In the present study area, early summer is the rainy season and direct typhoon passes occasionally occur during the summer. High precipitation and abundant nutrients supplied by terrestrial run-off cause an increase in chlorophyll a concentration a few days later (
The bacterial communities transitioned seasonally in the surface waters: from autumn–winter in 2018 (cluster 3-1) to winter–spring (cluster 4-4), rainy season before summer (cluster 4-2) and summer–autumn (cluster 2) in 2019 and to winter in 2019–2020 (cluster 3-3). The succession could be derived from the change of dominant taxa. Synechococcales and SAR11_clade were dominant in cluster 3-1, Flavobacteriales and Rhodobacterales became dominant in clusters 4-4 and 4-2. In cluster 2, Flabovacteriales, Rhodobacteriales, SAR11_clade, Synechococcales and cellvibrionales were evenly dominant. After that, SAR11_clade and Flavobacteriales became dominant. Flavobacteriales and Rhodobacterales are well known as copiotrophic taxa and respond quickly to the flux of fresh labile DOM derived from phytoplankton, subsequently outcompeting other community members as observed during phytoplankton blooms (
SAR11 was negatively correlated to Flavobacteriales and Rhodobacterales in the present study. The inverse correlation between those taxa was also observed in the coastal Southern Ocean (
SAR11 can be divided into several subclades, each of which has a different response to the environment (
Cyanobacteria were relatively abundant in clusters 2 and 3-1, accounting for up to 61% and DBRDA ordination revealed that cyanobacteria (Synechococcus_CC9902) were highly correlated with water temperature. The sporadic increase of cyanobacteria from summer to autumn is consistent with previous studies in the same Sagami Bay area (
SAR324_clade increased at deep waters (100 m depth) in summer and autumn, especially in October (5.4%), November (3.3%), December (6.1%) 2018 and July 2019 (5.8%). The results suggested that SAR324 gradually increased in their relative abundance several months after the MLD exceeded 100 m and vertical mixing occurs to the deeper layers. The seasonal variation agreed with a previous study reporting that SAR324 increased in the upper mesopelagic in autumn in the North Atlantic (
The present study revealed clear seasonal and vertical variations in the eukaryotic and bacterial communities consistent with changes in the environmental parameters. Eukaryotic and bacterial communities showed synchronous seasonal and vertical changes corresponding to the physical change; summer when the thermocline develops, winter when the mixed layer depth (MLD) is deep and transition periods that MLD gradually shallows (spring) and gradually deepens (autumn). In particular, DBRDA results suggested that the succession of eukaryotic and bacterial communities is closely related to the variations of the MLD, followed by nutrients for the eukaryotic community and temperature and chlorophyll a for the bacterial community.
The planktonic community was also vertically uniform in winter when vertical mixing formed a uniform water column and abiotic environment, although there was a slight time lag between the eukaryotic community (November–February) and the bacterial community (December–April). Productivity and biomass of bacterial communities are known to depend on eukaryote-derived resources (
Vertical characteristics of community diversity were different between the eukaryotic and bacterial communities; the lowest diversity was observed in the surface water in both communities, whereas the highest diversity was observed in intermediate depth layers (10–50 m) for the eukaryotic community and in the deeper layer (100 m) for the bacterial community. The number of OTUs and the Evenness were both low at the surface and 100 m layer in the eukaryotic community. The higher OTU number in the intermediate depth layers could be explained by seasonally changing MLD; the subsurface chlorophyll maxima (SCM), formed at the optimal depth where light availability and upward nutrient flux are sufficient to sustain phytoplankton growth in the water column, is characterised by a high species diversity of phytoplankton (
This research was supported by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) Global Change Observation Mission – Climate (GCOM-C) project grant JX-PSPC-524336 and a Grant-in-Aid (Establishing a network of environment and fisheries information) by the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan. We would like to thank all members of Team Manazuru in Yokohama National University and Soka University for observation support and members of Fisheries Research Institute, Japan Fisheries Research and Education Agency for measurement support.
Figures S1–S8
Data type: images
Explanation note: Figure S1. Cluster analysis results (group average) of eukaryotic (upper) and bacterial community (lower) in Sagami Bay. (A) Red lines represented results of SIMPROF test. (B) Each point represents each sample and different color represent each cluster. Figure S2. Taxonomic relative contributions to the bacterioplankton faction for each sample in Order level. Figure S3. Relative reads abundance of SAR11 subclades in SAR11 clade in each cluster. Figure S4. Spatiotemporal distributions of SAR11 subclades Ia, II and IV shown by their relative reads abundances in total bacterial community. Figure S5. Cluster analysis of diatom and relative reads abundance of top 15 OTUs classified to species level. Figure S6. Cluster analysis of dinoflagellates and relative reads abundance of top 15 OTUs classified to species level. Figure S7. Cluster analysis of green algae and relative reads abundance of top 15 OTUs classified to species level. Figure S8. Cluster analysis of haptophytes and relative reads abundance of top 15 OTUs classified to species level.